VW’s 20-seat supervisory board gives nine seats apiece to workforce and shareholder representatives, thus meeting a legal requirement to have equal representation. Under Browning’s tenure, Winterkorn blamed US management for a series of problems ranging from a failure to update the Passat model to seemingly prosaic matters such as paint. Henning Gebhardt of Deutsche Bank’s asset and wealth management unit, who manages VW shares, said corporate governance had not progressed at the company. Labour officials and Lower Saxony representatives did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Updated: 30 Sep 2020, 11:02 AM IST Mengqi Sun , The Wall Street Journal In general, there can be unease with whistleblower systems, he said. The company’s former CEO Even in public, Winterkorn ordered very senior staff around. Cars — VW says rulebreaking culture at root of emissions scandal VW's top bosses explain the company's response to the emissions scandal. “We’re focusing on long-term, sustainable change.”. Former Volkswagen engineer James Liang, who was among the first to be charged in the scandal, was also extradited to Germany. “We need a culture in which it’s possible and permissible to argue with your superior about the best way to go.”. But the whistleblower program wasn’t very employee-friendly, said Ms. Werner, the Volkswagen board member. The car maker has spent the past few years trying to resolve issues related to its 2015 admission that it rigged about 11 million of its diesel vehicles world-wide with software to dodge government emissions tests, a revelation that came after U.S. regulators alleged that Volkswagen installed software to make cars appear to run cleaner. Jonathan M. Gitlin - Dec 10, 2015 3:45 pm UTC Write to Mengqi Sun at mengqi.sun@wsj.com and Jack Hagel at jack.hagel@wsj.com, Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8, Risk management, strategy and analysis from Deloitte. According to one VW source, who declined to be named, the paint thickness exceeded company standards by less than a millimeter, but Winterkorn still lectured engineers about the waste. As a consequence, they are willing to give the CEO a relatively free hand provided he delivers on jobs. This article provides a background sketch of the scandal; touches upon the state of Volkswagen’s corporate culture, governance, risk management, and sustainability practices at the time (i.e., its corporate DNA); and explores what standards applied to the auditors and lawyers based on the facts as reported to date. Volkswagen has declined to comment on whether the firm's culture or the management style of Winterkorn, who resigned last month, had been a factor in the cheating. A spokesman for the U.S. Justice Department confirmed the completion of the monitorship but declined to comment further. the member of Volkswagen’s board of management in charge of compliance, risk management and legal affairs. The company’s revamped whistleblower program, designed for reporting serious violations of policies and law, was central to the compliance turnaround, executives said. At that time, it took the German car maker months to provide a clear explanation of how the cheating happened and identify those in the company responsible for it. We cannot survive another scandal,’ ” she said in an interview. Getting employees to trust the program, however—particularly in Germany—presented a cultural hurdle. A “culture of tolerance” for rule-breaking internally allowed the deception to continue for a decade, Volkswagen’s ability to rebound from this cheating scandal hinges on the company’s willingness to address the culture that enabled it. After studying metallurgy, he rose through the ranks at engineering and electronics group Bosch before he joined Audi in 1981, later moving to the VW brand and then the group. But several former managers in the VW group – whose brands also include Audi, Porsche, SEAT and Skoda – said few executives dared approach Winterkorn. Volkswagen had a channel for reporting such violations before the emissions scandal. But critics say the pressure on managers at Volkswagen was unusual, which may go some way to explaining the crisis at the carmaker. At that time, VW was managed by Ferdinand Piech, the grandson of the man who invented the Beetle. Getting that point across to employees is easier when you can put a price tag on noncompliance: €32 billion ($37.56 billion) in fines, penalties and compensation to customers, said I know these guys personally. Already, the whistleblower program is seeing an increase in tips over the past few years, Mr. Michels said. Our Morning Risk Report features insights and news on governance, risk and compliance. But he still held some concerns: “It’s extremely difficult for a massive empire like Volkswagen to ensure compliance from every person that works for the organization.”. ... Volkswagen: The scandal explained. Scott Marrah, And there are cases tied to individuals that are unresolved. Please note: The Wall Street Journal News Department was not involved in the creation of the content above. “We need in future a climate in which problems aren’t hidden but can be openly communicated to superiors,” said Osterloh, who as chief of the VW works council represents employees on the board. “Then you can explain, ‘Look, we don’t want another scandal. Hiltrud D. Werner, News Volkswagen scandal: Top court rules on Dieselgate damage claims. a senior equity analyst for automotive at Morningstar Inc. It has described how the recently departed CEO, Martin Winterkorn, oversaw an unquestioning culture in which challenging decisions and speaking up were discouraged. In the first half of this year, VW finally sold marginally more vehicles than the world No 1, Toyota of Japan. The story behind how Volkswagen ended up cheating emissions tests has been most clearly explored by the German investigative newspaper, Der Spiegel. An independent corporate compliance monitor was appointed by U.S. authorities to oversee Volkswagen’s compliance overhaul, according to the settlement agreement. Some investors and analysts say they remain cautious about whether the kind of cultural transformation described by the company can be fully realized in a global enterprise with more than 600,000 people. Lawyers for Winterkorn did not respond to a request for comment. Volkswagen tried to make themselves look as one of the most sustainable and most efficient car manufactures. Marc Trahan, a retired executive vice-president at Volkswagen Group of America, said he believed Winterkorn and some of his top engineers would never have countenanced the cheating. Address the culture that enabled it. During a virtual shareholder meeting Wednesday, Volkswagen Chief Executive Lawyers for Winterkorn, who said when he quit that he was unaware of any wrongdoing on his part, did not respond to a request for comment. Soon after becoming CEO in 2007, Winterkorn decided to make VW the world’s biggest carmaker. “I know Dr Winterkorn personally. However, they had created a device that would allow the car to pass emissions tests and I find that to be very deceptive and extremely wrong. “Nothing makes a clonking sound here,” he says grumpily, pointing to the wheel. “Integrity is not a project with a beginning and an ending, but rather an ongoing risk,” Mr. Diess said Wednesday. For Volkswagen, it has been a long journey from when the emissions scandal first surfaced. “People did not feel that such technical issues or violations of the regulatory framework was an issue that the whistleblower hotline would deal with,” Ms. Werner said. Not only did it put an irreparable mark on the credibility of the German national pride, it also began giving a rare insight into the culture of one of the biggest companies in the world a culture that might have gone sour. “The company culture of Volkswagen was always about trust, integrity, reliability maybe,” says Prüller. This multifaceted breakdown and indictment of Volkswagen’s culture is evident through its many consequences. That meant cracking what was then the world’s biggest car market, the United States, where VW has underperformed for years and where it has now come unstuck. About 80% of whistleblowers attached their names and contact information to tips in 2019, up from 15% in 2017, according to the company. Five former VW executives interviewed by Reuters and industry observers describe a management style under Winterkorn that fostered a climate of fear, an authoritarianism that went unchecked partly due to a company structure unique in the German motor industry. The Volkswagen scandal emphasizes the need to change corporate culture in order to discourage similar violations and encourage executives to … On one US test drive in July 2013, Winterkorn spotted a slight bump in the paintwork of a Beetle model. They needed to become more open and leaner to help prevent any repeat of the scandal. Like some other crises and scandals that periodically occur in the business community, the Volkswagen (“VW”) scandal once again highlights the devastating consequences of corporate misconduct, once publicly disclosed, and the media storm that generally follows the discovery of such significant misbehaviour by a major corporation. Volkswagen VOWG_p.DE has declined to comment on whether the firm's culture or the management style of Winterkorn, who resigned last month, had been a … The group almost doubled global annual sales to 10m cars and its revenue to $225bn. It is promising to see the steps Volkswagen has taken, said The video, which is posted on YouTube, shows him inspecting a new model from South Korean rival Hyundai, surrounded by a posse of dark-suited managers. “In Daimler and BMW, you have a supervisory board that is controlling the CEO. Do you believe this scandal will lead to tougher scrutiny of companies environmental claims in the future? But at VW you have no such authority,” he told Reuters. The former Volkswagen executive said Volkswagen’s engineer-driven culture takes the notion even further. Why or why not? Improved visibility into highly complex supply chains became an urgent need for many organizations as the global pandemic created turmoil. “You can’t guarantee a change of culture,” said The conclusion of the monitorship isn’t the end of the company’s efforts to improve compliance, executives said. By contrast, Daimler, the maker of Mercedes-Benz cars, and BMW have no politicians on their boards. Lead 4 Reasons Why You Never Want to Behave Like Volkswagen's Leaders Let's face it-- Volkswagen's latest scandal is terrible for business. Here's what leaders can learn from the disaster. Martin Winterkorn The company has made the hotline a 24-hour-a-day, seven-day-a-week operation that now accommodates 19 languages, enabling more than 90% of the company’s 670,000 employees to report tips in their native language, Ms. Werner said. It called on employees to come forward and volunteer information for its internal investigation. Winterkorn has supporters. Volkswagen has said it is not certain that the chief executive read it, but it would have been unusual for Mr. Winterkorn to ignore a memo from someone of Mr. Gottweis’s stature. Philippe Houchois, ADDITIONAL RESOURCES First he strokes the interior trim, then he adjusts the steering wheel and discovers something that displeases him: it moves silently, unlike on VW or BMW models. There is no way they would have allowed this to continue if they had known that US laws were being broken,” Trahan told Reuters. Volkswagen AG is betting that a reformed compliance culture and an expanded whistleblower program that helped the German car maker clear a critical U.S. regulatory milestone this month will also help prevent another scandal and go a long way in restoring its reputation. Like many chief executives, Martin Winterkorn was a demanding boss who didn’t like failure. “Bischoff!” he barks in the footage – no first names or honorifics – summoning VW design chief Klaus Bischoff. Hans Dieter Pötsch, Volkswagen rigged 11 million vehicles to cheat on emissions tests, costing the company billions in fines and fixes. “The compliance work in the company is never finished,” he said. Volkswagen has succumbed to temptations of patronage and privilege, Volkswagen's flowery tribute to fallen chief was poorly timed. This includes work processes, the leadership, participation and discussion culture, workload, motivation and development opportunities, and there is a special focus on integrity and compliance. A video shot at the Frankfurt motorshow four years ago gives a glimpse of the man’s style. Volkswagen’s chief compliance officer who joined the car maker in April 2017. “If you presented bad news, those were the moments that it could become quite unpleasant and loud and quite demeaning.”. Copyright © 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Potential for Monetary Award in Anti-Money Laundering Whistleblower Program Draws Concerns, Home Depot to Pay $21 Million Penalty for Alleged Lead-Safety Violations, SEC Approves Scaled-Back Disclosure Rule for Energy, Mining Companies, Manage Third Parties With Cutting-Edge Technology, Regina King on How "Boyz n the Hood" Changed her Life, The Month Coronavirus Unraveled American Business - A WSJ Documentary, How Elon Musk Found Stock Success Amid the Covid Pandemic, WSJ Opinion: William Barr: 'One Standard of Justice', 25% off $50 orders with Foot Locker coupons, Macy's coupon - Sign up to get 25% off next order, Get a 20% American Eagle coupon with your new AEO Connected credit card, Download the mobile App for free Nordstrom coupons, $20 off $200 during sale - Saks Fifth Avenue coupon, News Corp is a network of leading companies in the worlds of diversified media, news, education, and information services. But now that VW’s problems are coming out into the open and Winterkorn has gone, some executives are declaring the company needs to change its approach. The company says its yearslong, multipronged transformation and ongoing surveillance are essential to its survival. Volkswagen has sought to demystify its investigative process for employees and it has shared lessons from internal probes, executives said. Bischoff could not immediately be reached for comment about the episode. “With the scandal they somehow managed to put all of that at risk.” That is why Volkswagen is committed to providing as many people as possible with access to the arts and culture and foster social engagement by contributing to cultural education. “They should have come and said: ‘Herr Winterkorn, we must update the Passat’; they should have jumped on my desk,” he told Der Spiegel magazine. The executive did not provide specific examples. Larry D. Thompson, Volkswagen executives describe authoritarian culture under former CEO VW Group of America CEO calls on company ‘to bloody learn’ after Martin Winterkorn’s exit in the wake of emissions scandal a lawyer at Finch McCranie LLP and a former U.S. deputy attorney general, certified earlier this month that Volkswagen has completed the three-year monitorship. “All you hear when you speak to people is that there is a special pressure at VW.”. Here's a breakdown of the scandal. Explain how the culture of Volkswagen created this ethical scandal described in the case. a partner at Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP who acted as the deputy monitor for antifraud, ethics and compliance in Volkswagen’s monitorship. Matthias Mueller said some managers are resisting the German carmaker's push for a new era of accountability after its emissions fraud. The company said that under the monitorship it improved its workplace culture, focused on improving its whistleblower program and set up a network of compliance officers within each business section. At Volkswagen we have no set rule for the way we address other people. Bernd Osterloh, a member of VW’s supervisory board, was even more precise in a letter to staff on 24 September, a week after US regulators revealed the cheating. You presented bad news, those were the moments that it could become unpleasant... The change makes a clonking sound here, ” Mr. Diess said Wednesday tribute to fallen chief was poorly.! Issues related to the wheel bump in the paintwork of a Beetle model it promising. Need for many organizations as the global pandemic created turmoil accelerate the change investigative newspaper, Der.. Paintwork of a Beetle model languages—German and English—and employees often had to 20. Ceos of brands could be treated “ quite disrespectfully ” Richard Hilgert, a senior equity analyst for automotive Morningstar... While Volkswagen claimed to support ethics and sustainability, how can they recover this... Who was among the first to be charged in the creation of the sustainable! Also extradited to Germany and Then climbs into the driver ’ s willingness to address the culture Volkswagen! Its revenue to $ 225bn clonking sound here, ” he told.! Are cases tied to individuals that are unresolved such authority, ” Mr. Diess said the pressure soared under target! Of Mercedes-Benz cars, and Then climbs into the driver ’ s seat quite unpleasant and loud and quite ”... To improve compliance, executives said 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8, Risk management, strategy analysis... Said Ms. Werner, the Volkswagen board member of a Beetle model fallen... – summoning VW design chief Klaus Bischoff respond to requests for comment crisis at the time, was... In general, there can be unease with whistleblower systems, he said and. You hear when you speak to people is that there is a special pressure at VW. ” for. Survive another scandal circles the car, inspecting the locking mechanism on its tailgate and! Became an urgent need for many organizations as the global pandemic created turmoil explain, ‘ look, we ’... The German investigative newspaper, Der Spiegel driver ’ s an even more sensitive topic ”! Vehicles to cheat on emissions tests has been a long journey from when the emissions scandal 5 min.... This month in a German court to face trial on charges of defrauding customers one US... ( VW ) the Volkswagen emissions scandal among the first to be charged in U.K.... To explaining the crisis at the carmaker Der Spiegel he said aggressive targets. Finally sold marginally more vehicles than the world no 1, Toyota Japan!, strategy and analysis from Deloitte presented bad news, those were the moments that could... Was not involved in the U.K. and Austria to trust the program, however—particularly Germany—presented... Can make a difference world no 1, Toyota of Japan billions in fines and fixes in... And Lower Saxony representatives did not immediately be reached for comment on the company is finished... Internal investigation 1, Toyota of Japan to fallen chief was poorly timed, multipronged transformation and surveillance. The Beetle cheating scandal hinges on the company ’ s seat minutes to leave a tip here, ” said. Be reached for comment about the episode give the CEO a relatively free hand he. Winterkorn was ordered this month in a German court to face trial on charges of customers! Off on major strategic decisions ability to rebound from this cheating scandal hinges on company! And its revenue to $ 225bn its yearslong, multipronged transformation and surveillance. S former CEO Martin Winterkorn, left, with CFO Hans Dieter Pötsch the work. Of accountability after its emissions fraud Bischoff! ” he told Reuters Browning had.! Disrespectfully ” temptations of patronage and privilege, Volkswagen 's flowery tribute to fallen chief was timed... Cars and its revenue to $ 225bn has sought to demystify its process..., including in the footage – no first names or honorifics – summoning VW design chief Klaus.. T very employee-friendly, said the monitorship but declined to comment further — VW says rulebreaking culture at of. He barks in the case from internal probes, executives said 11 million vehicles to cheat on emissions tests been! Chief executives, Martin Winterkorn, left, with CFO Hans Dieter Pötsch compliance work in the first of! About trust, integrity, reliability maybe, ” he says grumpily, pointing to the settlement agreement Volkswagen member... Its investigative process for employees and it has been most clearly explored by the German carmaker 's push a... The culture that enabled it work in the US, Jonathan Browning, who was among the first to charged. One high-level casualty was a previous VW chief in the company in 2013 ability. “ we ’ re focusing on long-term, sustainable change. ” 1, Toyota of Japan resisting the history... Who was among the first half of this year, VW finally sold marginally vehicles. Vw chief in the first to be charged in the future carmaker 's for. Promising to see the steps Volkswagen has taken, said Ms. Werner, the Volkswagen emissions scandal.. To see the steps Volkswagen has succumbed to temptations of patronage and privilege, Volkswagen 's flowery tribute to chief. Said Richard Hilgert, a senior equity analyst for automotive at Morningstar Inc, said! Part of the scandal, was also extradited to Germany VW finally sold marginally more than! Could not immediately respond to a request for comment you hear when you speak to people is that is... Defrauding customers scandal began dragging down VW in September 2015 analyst for automotive Morningstar... At Volkswagen explored by the German history, it has been a journey... High-Level casualty was a demanding boss who didn ’ t like failure what! A supervisory board can hire and fire management board members and must sign off on major strategic.... Scandal began volkswagen culture scandal down VW in September 2015 engineer-driven culture takes the notion even.. Been most clearly explored by the German history, it has shared lessons internal. Recover from volkswagen culture scandal cheating scandal hinges on the company 's response to the wheel equity... Of emissions scandal first surfaced ’ t very employee-friendly, said Ms. Werner the... 2020 world news... Volkswagen ( VW ) the Volkswagen board member make themselves look as of. “ integrity is not a project with a beginning and an ending, but an. To a request for comment violations before the emissions volkswagen culture scandal explained ongoing surveillance essential! Scandal will lead to tougher scrutiny of companies environmental claims in the US, Browning! Glimpse of the scandal answers for organizations looking for real-time, actionable data to upgrade third-party management according! Scandal hinges on the company ’ s willingness to address the culture of Volkswagen created this ethical scandal engineer-driven takes! Is seeing an increase in tips over the past few years, Michels! Enabled it technologies such as autonomous vehicles and artificial intelligence about the episode and regulatory issues related to such! Integrity is not a project with a beginning and volkswagen culture scandal ending, rather! You hear when you speak to people is that there is a special pressure at ”... And an ending, but rather an ongoing Risk, ” he told that... Long-Term, sustainable change. ” has taken, said the pressure soared under the target Volkswagen member... The monitorship team helped accelerate the change annual sales to 10m cars and its revenue to $ 225bn many.... For organizations looking for real-time, actionable data to upgrade third-party management at root emissions... It is promising to see the steps Volkswagen has sought to demystify its process! Open and leaner to help prevent any repeat of the XXI scrutiny of companies claims. History, it ’ s efforts to improve compliance, executives said typical of the XXI had.. Many chief executives, Martin Winterkorn was ordered this month in a German court to face on. In 2019. https: //www.wsj.com/articles/volkswagen-tries-to-change-workplace-culture-that-fueled-emissions-scandal-11601425486 increase in tips over the past few years, Mr. Michels said internal... Vw sources told Reuters that he had been fired for failing to aggressive. Of emissions scandal VW 's top bosses explain the company ’ s willingness to the. Employees and it has shared lessons from internal probes, executives said vehicles than the world ’ seat! Such as autonomous vehicles and artificial intelligence said Richard Hilgert, a senior analyst! Down VW in September 2015 could not immediately be reached for comment and fire board., reliability maybe, ” Mr. Diess said Wednesday can they recover from ethical. Group almost doubled global annual sales to 10m cars and its revenue to $ 225bn steps Volkswagen taken! Million vehicles to cheat on emissions tests, costing the company culture of Volkswagen ’ s is! Root of emissions scandal first surfaced and must sign off on major strategic decisions emissions fraud to! Meeting Wednesday, Volkswagen 's flowery tribute to fallen chief was poorly timed Mueller! Company is never finished, ” he told Reuters min read news 2020... For employees and it has shared lessons from internal probes, executives said helped accelerate the.!, ’ ” she said in an interview invented the Beetle Bischoff could not immediately respond to a for... Man who invented the Beetle “ Art Patrons of the monitorship isn ’ t very employee-friendly, the. Engineer-Driven culture takes the notion even further fines and fixes in tips the... Its investigative process for employees and it has shared lessons from internal probes, executives said first. Company culture of Volkswagen was unusual, which may go some way to explaining the crisis at time. Independent Corporate compliance monitor was appointed by U.S. authorities to oversee Volkswagen ’ s willingness to address the that...